Filtrer par :

Note moyenne

  • Note globale
  • Facilité d'utilisation
  • Service client

En savoir plus sur Magnolia

Un CMS headless pour les entreprises qui souhaitent créer des expériences digitales uniques et mémorables.

En savoir plus sur Magnolia

22 avis affichés

Julien M.
Julien M.
Marketing Manager (France)
Utilisateur LinkedIn vérifié
Logiciels, 51-200 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Fluide, facile et efficace - parfait pour un Website Content Manager

5 il y a 8 mois

Avantages :

Le logiciel offre de nombreuses fonctionnalités et est très intuitif. Pour créer de nouvelles pages, de nouveaux components et les éditer ensuite, tout est très facile (aussi facile qu'avec des programmes de type Elementor) et user-friendly, tout en apportant plus de possibilités qu'avec les programmes plus "basiques". Il est possible d'intégrer des programmes externes très facilement pour faire communiquer le CMS avec les autres softwares que l'on utilise déjà (CRM, eShop, etc.) J'ai été sur Magnolia 2 ans, quasi quotidiennement en tant qu'utilisateur.

Inconvénients :

Seule la version Enterprise offre l'ensemble des features, donc pas fait pour les plus petites PMEs avec un budget Digital limité, cependant une version Community est disponible.

Andrew E.
Andrew E.
Managing Director (R.-U.)
Utilisateur LinkedIn vérifié
Logiciels, 11-50 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Our go-to CMS platform

5 il y a 2 ans

Commentaires : Our primary goal is unifying data and making it easy for clients to manage their various pieces of data and assets which are often scattered across various systems. Having a centralised interface with one set of logins and where applicable one set of design templates makes it easier to extend applications and keep things tidy. We also don't have to put a lot of effort in to infrastructure as the system performs pretty well without having lots of additional reverse proxies and caches in place. It just works. That's all we and indeed our clients want.

Avantages :

We implement a number of different CMS platforms and the team have been doing this for over twenty years. Magnolia is a system we keep coming back to because it's reliable, easy to work with and contains the right balance of features to help us give clients the functionality they want without adding extraneous features. For an enterprise grade system, it's also pretty good from a budget point of view. Our clients respond positively to the intuitive interface and that means a lower support overhead for us.

Inconvénients :

Up until the last year or two, the company were not particularly customer or indeed integrator friendly. Thankfully this has since changed.

Joaquin A.
Software engineer (Espagne)
Services et technologies de l'information, Auto-entrepreneur
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Clean and high performance open source CMS

5 l’année dernière

Commentaires : I met Magnolia because I was required for a company to evaluate it. I started from the commercial website of Magnolia and it was enough to create the POC and deploy the product in a few time.

Avantages :

From the point of view of a software engineer what I like more is the architecture and design of the product - it is simple and brilliant - and also the cleanliness of the code and the usage of design principles and recommendations for Java developing. The above pros allows Magnolia to be robust, reliable and at the same time dynamic and flexible because it is really easy to customize and adapt the product to the requirements of the installation. As standard java product it is really easy to deploy it in any IT infrastructure: cloud, cluster of dockers, on premise etc. Another feature I like is headless that allows you to integrate Magnolia with other services to consume and expose contents from/to other services or systems. As a user, Magnolia is simple to use and easy to learn - it remembers me the "Kiss" principle - and full of features that helps content editors.

Inconvénients :

The community of Magnolia is active but It is small, there is a lot of help and docs from official community but non-official or partners are not so involved.

Alternatives envisagées : Liferay DXP

Pourquoi choisir Magnolia : The following issues with the current product: low performance, lack of documentation, bugs and poor support. It was a proprietary product and it was not possible to customize or even improve it.

Pourquoi passer à Magnolia : Main reason was that it is Open source and easy to customize. The usage of java as programming language was also important. The modular design of magnolia allowed to integrate Magnolia better inside the infrastructure. Headless skills. Magnolia had better performance than alternative products.

Antonio josé M.
Antonio josé M.
Arquitecto - Jefe de equipo (Espagne)
Utilisateur LinkedIn vérifié
Internet, 10 000+ employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Buen producto para los proyectos adecuados

3 l’année dernière

Commentaires : Mi experiencia en general es buena, es un producto muy valido para realizar proyectos web que tengan una serie de caracteristicas bastante claras. Es un jugador de nicho que intenta expandir el terreno de juego.

Avantages :

Su interfaz es intuitiva y sencilla. Su arquitectura admite una profunda personalización ajustandose a las necesidades de cada cliente. Su API para gestionar contenidos es de las mejores en productos de este tipo. El renderizado de las páginas es bastante sencillo y ajustado; no tener que lidiar con trozos de HTML inyectados por el CMS es una ventaja a la hora de integrar todas las partes. Su rendimiento es bastante bueno para ser un CMS basado en Java. Su apuesta por el desarrollo Front como alternativa viable para casi todo es un acierto mayusculo que permite ahorrar tiempo de implementación.

Inconvénients :

SI bien en las opciones en las que es bueno es mejor que la mayoria de competidores tecnológicamente equivalente, no es buena opción para proyectos que no estén dentro de su rango natural de actuación. La curva de dificultad a la hora de realizar implementaciones crece exponencialmente en cuanto te sales de lo que ofrece el producto. No tiene una comunidad amplia que te ayude o de soporte. No tiene un marketplace amplio que te permita reutilizar desarrollos. No tienen demasiados conectores para integrarse con otros softwares.

Alternatives envisagées : WordPress, Liferay DXP et Drupal

Pourquoi choisir Magnolia : En los proyectos en los cuales MagnoliaCMS es bueno es mejor que Liferay DXP

Logiciel antérieur : Liferay Portal

Pourquoi passer à Magnolia : Combina mejor seguridad y soporte que las alternativas PHP y mas sencillez de implementación que las alternativas Java en aquellos proyectos que están dentro de su rango de actuación.

Leigh W.
Managing Director (R.-U.)
Internet, 11-50 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Why Magnolia

5 l’année dernière

Commentaires : Running an Agency Magnolia stands out because of the ease of use, empowerment and speed of development, 3 things which are important in ensuring client deliveries and retaining customers.

Avantages :

When evaluating CMS's it is important to consider the end user needs, the people that will be using it on a day to day basis. Whilst having all of the Enterprise features Magnolia wins on ease of use, logically laid out the user interface empowers content editors, and authors to get on with telling stories and day to day marketing/merchandising of the website whether Ecommerce or B2B. Add to ease of use features like campaign management and personalisation along with open integration and tools then the platform becomes very powerful.

Inconvénients :

Like most Enterprise CMS platforms there is a lot of functionality under the bonnet and it requires expertise to ensure that the approach taken for a particular part of a site development is the right one, but once selected provides a firm foundation to build upon.

Alternatives envisagées : Content Hub

Pourquoi choisir Magnolia : Often switching clients onto Magnolia as the open framework and empowerment tools makes it easier to deliver client requirements.

Pourquoi passer à Magnolia : ease of use, speed of implementation, openness

Ricardo B.
Senior Content Manager (Ukraine)
Internet, 2-10 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus d'un an
Source de l'avis

Magnolia CMS provides a great digital experience

5 il y a 10 mois

Commentaires : Magnolia CRM was a great complement on our current content management infrstructure. Thanks to its highly modular structure we could implement it with ease.

Avantages :

Magnolia has an extremely modular structure that enabled it to be integrated to our current business management infrastructure. Magnolia helps us to deliver our central content any end user distribution channel.

Inconvénients :

Magnolia is really an extemely huge CRM that requires a considerable amount of time and efford to have an expertise on all features of the platform.

Alternatives envisagées : SmartTouch ECM

Pourquoi choisir Magnolia : Magnolia CRM was a better option in terms of ease of integration to our existing business management infrastructure.

Logiciel antérieur : SmartTouch ECM

Pourquoi passer à Magnolia : Magnolia CRM had more modular structure and this was the key point that effected our decision.

Sebastian N.
Director of Technology Solutions (É.-U.)
Logiciels, 11-50 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Magnolia as an ideal Digital Experience integration platform

5 il y a 2 ans

Commentaires : Solving the content integration and personalization challenges of our clients and Magnolia is providing the tooling to achieve that goal with rapidly customizable features.

Avantages :

The best features of Magnolia besides it's great content editor experience is the ability to use the product in a traditional CMS approach by rendering web pages and as a headless CMS. It provides great flexibility on both fronts. Enterprise integration capabilities are also superb with available pre-built integration modules to popular applications like Salesforce and Google Analytics as well as Ecommerce. Overall a great platform to build and grow an Enterprise wide Digital Experience.

Inconvénients :

The platform is extensive and can be challenging from a development learning curve perspective.

Alternatives envisagées : Hippo CMMS

Pourquoi passer à Magnolia : Superior integration capabilities and better editor user experience.

David C.
David C.
DXP Architect (Espagne)
Utilisateur LinkedIn vérifié
Logiciels, 1 001-5 000 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Intuitivo, buena integrabilidad y abierto

4 l’année dernière

Commentaires : La experiencia en general ha sido muy buena, porque es un producto que desde el principio te sientes cómodo con él y sientes que puedes sacarle el máximo partido gracias a sus funcionalidades de caja, su posibilidad de personalización y el apoyo del fabricante.

Avantages :

Magnolia es un producto que destaca por varias de sus virtudes. Por una parte es muy fácil e intuitivo de usar para usuarios no técnicos. Además tiene un time-to-market muy acotado que permite realizar su implantación en muy poco tiempo. Destaca también su filosofía de código abierto que permite adecuar el producto a las necesidades específicas de cada cliente. Es un producto con potentes herramientas de marketing como la personalización de los contenidos (targeting) o las herramientas SEO p.ej. Destaca también la buena integrabilidad gracias a sus connector packs y su API REST de serie. Su arquitectura es escalable, lo que permite adaptar y optimizar el dimensionamiento a las necesidades de cada momento. El soporte del fabricante es bueno y siempre brindan el apoyo necesario tanto a partners como a clientes. Es un producto en constante evolución por lo que las mejoras de seguridad, rendimiento, funcionalidad, etc las obtiene directamente el cliente sin coste adicional por ellas. Permite desacoplar la capa frontal, por lo que se pueden hacer desarrollos basado en tecnologías actuales como Angular, ReactJS, VueJS, etc, dotando de dinamismo a las páginas.

Inconvénients :

Quizá se eche de menos un sistema más automático de desinstalación de módulos. Por otra parte, a pesar de contar con herramientas de backups donde las copias de seguridad son muy fáciles de programar, la restauración ha de hacerse de una forma un poco manual. Respecto a las integraciones de caja con otras herramientas o fabricantes, se echan de menos algunas aunque están evolucionando bien en ese sentido

Claudia M.
Claudia M.
Responsable de proyectos (Espagne)
Utilisateur LinkedIn vérifié
Développement de programmes, 501-1 000 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Magnolia, el gestor de contenidos adaptable

5 l’année dernière

Commentaires : Llevo trabajando con Magnolia algo más de 7 años, es una plataforma muy completa con la cual hasta ahora hemos podido cubrir todas las funcionalidades que nos han solicitado. Además debido a que está en constante evolución he podido estar al día en cuanto a las tendencias en desarrollo front e integrar frameworks como bootstrap, REACT, etc gracias a su arquitectura headless, así como en el back, donde ahora podemos trabajar con estructuras más complejas gracias a la Inteligencia Artificial en la que han ido trabajando para su backend.

Avantages :

Este gestor de contenidos posee una arquitectura modular que ofrece la posibilidad de poder integrar cualquier servicio y realizar desarrollos basados en microservicios que pueden ser reutilizados, incluso,k por cualquier otra plataforma gracias a la API que nos proporciona. De esta manera he podido cubrir cualquier necesidad que al cliente se le plantee, obteniendo no solo un portal web si no pudiendo integrar cualquier funcionalidad, permitiendo cubrir las necesidades del mismo en un tiempo récord.

Inconvénients :

Estaría bien contar ya con módulos orientados a trabajar con foros o blog, dónde se de la iniciativa de tener un lugar donde colaborar con los usuarios públicos. No obstante, con el sistema de plantillado y la posibilidad de trabajar con workspaces en cluster es posible desarrollarlos fácilmente.

Utilisateur vérifié
Chief Technology officer (É.-U.)
Utilisateur LinkedIn vérifié
Sécurité et enquêtes, 11-50 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus d'un an
Source de l'avis

Distancing itself as an Enterprise solution

5 il y a 2 ans

Avantages :

Our team is comprised of Java and Web Developers. We had been using WordPress which was a big task for us as our expertise didn't lie in PHP. Then we stumbled on Magnolia and it wasn't that it was just a Java based product. The ease at which we were able to build the custom modules we needed and plug it into our other solutions like Salesforce. Helped us reduce our time spent in implementing and provide a quicker turnaround for new features to our business team. Which in turn sped up our ROI on Magnolia.

Inconvénients :

The only issue we seem to have at this point is there are not a lot of OOB integrations to popular solutions like NetSuite or Salesforce and everything pretty much has to be custom built. I think if Magnolia did that there would be very few competitors for them.

Alternatives envisagées : Adobe Experience Manager

Logiciel antérieur : WordPress

Emilio M.
DevOps Engineer (Espagne)
Hôtellerie, 10 000+ employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Why should I recommend Magnolia CMS?

5 il y a 2 ans

Commentaires : From DevOps perspective Magnolia CMS gives us the ability to clone environments very easily, with low cost in infrastructure. It's amazing how Magnolia CMS can manage high loads without issues using not too large machines. Of course backups are another strong point in Magnolia CMS with easy integration with Cloud solutions.

Avantages :

Is amazing how easy is to integrate Magnolia CMS in our continuous delivery cycle. We use Magnolia CMS over Tomcat and the behavior is the same than others Tomcat based solutions we already had in the company.

Inconvénients :

We would like to control the publication of content between different public instances and not others. For example, I want to publish this content only in this public instances to test something new.

Gonzalo R.
Líder Técnico (Espagne)
Services et technologies de l'information, 1 001-5 000 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Un gestor ágil y flexible

5 l’année dernière

Commentaires : Trabajo a diario desarrollando portales sobre Magnolia y la verdad es que de los CMS con los que he trabajado este es el mejor, es sencillo de implementar lo que hace que la curva de aprendizaje sea muy suave. Es súper flexible, lo que nos permite adaptarnos fácilmente a las necesidades del cliente. Y permite la integración casi con cualquier aplicación.

Avantages :

Lo que más destacaría del gestor es su facilidad de uso, y su flexibilidad. Desde el minuto uno los usuarios son independientes de IT para poder crear páginas o contenidos. Y desde el punto de vista técnico nos permite integrarnos con multitud de aplicativos.

Inconvénients :

Echo de menos algún tipo de acelerador con un catálogo de componente base de los que partir, le restaría un poco de flexibilidad pero permitiría acelerar los desarrollos.

Dayana J.
Dayana J.
dayana (É.-U.)
Utilisateur LinkedIn vérifié
Gestion d'organisme à but non lucratif, 1 001-5 000 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : 1 à 5 mois
Source de l'avis

Mangolia is An attractive content management system,Highly recommended

5 il y a 2 ans

Commentaires : Magnolia CMS is an amazing tool for the development of an innovative websites, intranets, and extra-nets. It enables you to launch your apps or websites without generating new content. It allows you to re-utilize and reorganize your present content into little, recyclable blocks. So, you can provide content to the visitors related to their interests. Magnolia offers easy access to customize the pages and content through its friendly web-based applications.

Avantages :

Magnolia is an open, extendable and a flexible tool and its standard features can be changed and expanded. It provides a centralized solution for the users with the characteristics for sending an appealing digital experience to all the channels, markets, and brands. Integration of other software’s can be done using Java API, REST, SOAP, CMIS, XML, etc. Magnolia is a high-quality platform for enterprise IT system which is written in Java. It is firm, accessible, and safe and separates the performance from the public settings. Magnolia offers easy access to customize the pages and content through its friendly web-based applications.

Inconvénients :

There is a lack of an administrative control panel in Magnolia, displaying all the workflow, most probably in graphical representation. The developer must know how to use Vaadin in order to implement the customization in the administrative UI of Magnolia. The uninstall of the modules is quite unsystematic. There are no chances to go back if an error occurs during the publication of new versions of a self-made module. It is not mobile or tablet friendly.

Stanley J.
Technology Lead (R.-U.)
Services et technologies de l'information, 11-50 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : 1 à 5 mois
Source de l'avis

Magnolia - Our Next Generation Content Management System

4 l’année dernière

Avantages :

Ability to combine content management, digital marketing and ecommerce onto a single platform was a really good feature. The Visual SPA editor , was really user friendly for non-technical content authors, who had got back their ability to author digital experiences in the new era of web development tools and frameworks. Evolution of the product to evolve itself into a headless platform that can be hosted both on premise and on cloud made it easy to be placed on the new DXL (Digital Experience Layer) platform that we are building for one of our clients. Upgrades to latest editions 6.X were also seamless without any major hurdles. Modular architecture made it easy for us to build a new ecommerce connector at fast pace. Light module based development was a real boon , when it came to setting up feature teams comprising of FrontEnd and Java based BackEnd developers.

Inconvénients :

We would like the product to become for more cloud friendly and looking forward to see support for GraphQL based apis .

Tom D.
Technical Director (É.-U.)
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Magnolia is a great CMS platform with a great product and support team

5 il y a 4 ans

Avantages :

Magnolia excels in its ability to be adapted to specific enterprise content management needs. Everyone wants roughly the same core features but fine tuned to their business. Magnolia's flexibility makes this possible.

Inconvénients :

The underlying JCR technology is solid and stable but has not been updated in a while. Would be good to see more updates in this area and/or future vision.

Le vin C.
Director, Head of Marketing & Communications (Suisse)
Services et technologies de l'information, 11-50 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Few issues over the years

4 il y a 4 mois

Avantages :

As someone who had used other CMS before, Magnolia is very easy to grasp and use. over the past 6 years, there have been almost no occasions where we needed the helpline - we always solved the problems internally.

Inconvénients :

Our website is coded such that use beyond standard settings requires a developer to create new templates or adjust settings.

May T.
Delivery Director (É.-U.)
Services et technologies de l'information, 201-500 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

One of the most flexible WCM platforms out there!

5 l’année dernière

Avantages :

From end users onboarding to platform enablement, Magnolia is proven to be one of the front runner. Our team loves the extensibility of the platform. Definitely one of the most well rounded WCM out there from features to pricing.

Inconvénients :

Desired features: More robust translation workflow / connector, A/B/N Testing (in roadmap already)

Nathan P.
Front End Developer (É.-U.)
Marketing et publicité, 11-50 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Simple Yet Powerful

4 l’année dernière

Commentaires : It's an exceptional platform to swiftly build out templates that offer a wide range of flexibility to the content managers and endusers alike.

Avantages :

Wonderful CMS to develop on. Ease of development lets me focus on empowering content managers to deliver amazing end results.

Inconvénients :

Admin can feel a bit clunky at times. Especially in version 6 and later.

Jordi R.
Frontend developer (Espagne)
Hôtellerie, 10 000+ employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

A pleasant surprise

5 il y a 2 ans

Avantages :

It is a complete solution that has allowed us to migrate from a previous platform easily and quickly. In addition, the learning curve is excellent.

Inconvénients :

At the moment I have not found anything outstanding in lack.

Tom D.
Client Director (É.-U.)
Logiciels, 201-500 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : plus de deux ans
Source de l'avis

Powerful and easy to use DXP

5 l’année dernière

Avantages :

Very easy to use from an admin perspective. Non-technical resources can easily pick up admin functionality. Built in workflows are very impressive. Perfect enterprise DXP that both marketing and IT will love to use.

Inconvénients :

At this point I have no negative issues with Magnolia. Very happy with platform.

Julian M.
Sales Director (R.-U.)
Services et technologies de l'information, 1 001-5 000 employés
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : 6 à 12 mois
Source de l'avis

Magnolia - Fast and Easy, yet still industry strength

5 l’année dernière

Commentaires : Being able to reach our customers and give them the best experience.

Avantages :

The product is easy to configure and use, yet scalable and able to grow as business grow.

Inconvénients :

None so far, I've found it easy to use and flexible enough to address our requirements.

Abhay K.
R.-U.
Temps d'utilisation du logiciel : Non fourni
Source de l'avis

Developr-Friendly Open-Source Enterprise CMS

5 il y a 5 ans

Commentaires : I work for a digital consultancy that has experience of implementing various CMS products. From a systems integrator point of view, I like Magnolia not just for its strong feature-set, but because I know I can deliver robust and scalable solutions for our clients using this platform. Another bonus is an extensive set of well documented APIs that make it highly extensible and very developer-friendly. I also like that Magnolia is open-source and offers the free Community Edition as an entry point for smaller organisations.